Two families, not ten shapes
Before the names, the division that explains most of the behaviour.
Brilliant cuts have many small triangular and kite-shaped facets arranged to bounce light around inside the stone and throw it back out in flashes. Round, oval, pear, marquise, cushion, radiant and princess all work this way. They sparkle in the sense people mean when they say sparkle, and they are good at disguising things.
Step cuts have long parallel facets, like a staircase, and they do something entirely different. Light moves in broad planes rather than flashes. Emerald and asscher are the two you will meet. They look like still water rather than glitter, and they conceal almost nothing.
Most of diamond shapes explained properly comes down to which family you prefer, and nearly everyone has a strong reaction once they have seen both side by side.
What that difference means in practice
A brilliant cut is forgiving. All that faceting breaks up the interior, which means small inclusions are harder to see and faint body colour is harder to notice. You can buy slightly further down the clarity and colour scales and lose nothing visible.
A step cut is unforgiving in exactly those two ways. The open planes act like a window: inclusions sit on display and any warmth of colour shows plainly. The same stone specification that looks fine as an oval can look compromised as an emerald cut.
So the honest advice is that step cuts cost more than their carat price suggests, because they oblige you to buy better clarity and better colour to look right. That is rarely mentioned when they are being sold as the understated choice.
The shapes, briefly
Round brilliant. The most light return of any shape, the most researched proportions, and the only shape that routinely receives a full cut grade on a report. It is also the most expensive per carat, because it is in the greatest demand and because more rough is lost in cutting it.
Oval. A brilliant cut stretched. Covers more finger per carat than a round, which is why it looks larger at the same weight. Watch for the bow-tie — a dark band across the centre that appears in some ovals and not others, and which no grade predicts. Look at the specific stone.
Cushion. A squared outline with rounded corners. Softer flashes than a round, more fire, and generally good value. Available elongated or square, which changes the effect considerably.
Pear and marquise. Both elongated with points. Both lengthen a finger well. Both have a point that needs protecting, since a point is the most vulnerable part of any stone and should sit under metal.
Princess. Square brilliant. Sharp corners, strong sparkle, and corners that need claws over them for the same reason.
Radiant. A squared or rectangular outline with brilliant faceting, so it has the shape of an emerald cut and the behaviour of a brilliant. A reasonable answer for anyone who likes the outline but not the exposure.
Emerald. The step cut most people mean. Long, calm, architectural. Reads larger than its weight because of its spread, and demands better clarity than any other shape.
Asscher. A squarer step cut with cropped corners. Same honesty about clarity, with more depth to the effect.
Price, which nobody frames honestly
Round costs the most per carat. Every other shape costs less, often considerably, and not because they are lesser stones — because less rough is wasted producing them and demand is lower.
Which means shape is one of the few places where a preference saves money rather than costing it. If you were never set on a round, you are buying the same material for less.
What shape does to apparent size
Elongated shapes spread their weight across the finger rather than down into the stone, so they cover more surface per carat. An oval, pear or emerald of the same weight as a round will generally look larger on a hand.
This is why the carat number is a poor guide and the millimetre measurements are a good one. A forthcoming entry on shape and finger proportion covers how to compare them in about four seconds with a strip of paper.
Does origin change any of this
No. A lab-grown diamond is cut by the same people, to the same proportions, into the same shapes, and graded on the same scales. Everything above applies unchanged.
What changes is reach. At a given budget the lab-grown option generally puts a better cut grade or a larger stone within range, and for step cuts that matters more than usual — since clarity and colour carry more weight there, the extra room goes somewhere useful. The comparison with mined stones covers what genuinely differs.
Choosing
If you want the most sparkle, a round or a cushion. If you want calm rather than glitter, an emerald or asscher, specified better than you otherwise would. If you want apparent size, anything elongated. If you have loved one shape since you were fifteen, buy that one — every effect described here is a matter of degree, and nobody has ever grown fond of a ring they chose by argument.
For a commission the shape and dimensions are agreed before anything is made. Tell us which family you react to and the rest follows from that.