Journal

Reading a grading report without being impressed by it.

Most of the document is reference data. Three or four lines decide what the stone looks like, and the most useful part of the page is the one nobody is taught to read.

1 October 2026

What the document is for

A grading report describes a specific stone. It is produced by a laboratory, it carries a number tied to that stone, and it is a description rather than a recommendation. It says nothing about whether the stone is good value, and nothing about what it is worth.

Which is the first thing to hold on to when learning how to read a diamond grading report. The laboratory is not on anyone's side. It is measuring.

The lines that decide what you see

Cut grade. Where it appears, read it first. It is the only grade produced by human skill rather than by how the material turned out, and it governs how much light comes back out of the stone. Everything else on the page describes the material; this describes the work.

Note that a full cut grade is given for round brilliants and often not for other shapes, where you are left with the proportions instead. That is a real gap and it is why fancy shapes reward looking rather than reading.

Colour. A letter. Meaningful at the extremes, increasingly academic in the middle, and heavily influenced by the metal the stone ends up in.

Clarity. A code. The only threshold that matters for most people is whether inclusions are visible without magnification, and above that line a better grade buys a better certificate rather than a better-looking ring.

Carat. A weight, to two decimal places. Not a size. Two stones of equal weight can present differently across the top, which is why the measurements matter more than this number.

The part nobody is taught to read

Somewhere on the report there is a line of measurements in millimetres — the stone's actual dimensions.

This is the most practically useful line on the page and it is routinely ignored in favour of the carat weight. Millimetres tell you how much finger the stone will cover, which is what anyone looking at your hand actually perceives. Weight can hide in the depth of a badly proportioned stone where it does nothing except cost money.

Read the measurements, compare them against the width of the finger the ring is going on, and the whole question of apparent size resolves itself. A forthcoming entry on shape and proportion sets out how to do that in a couple of minutes.

The plotted diagram

Many reports include a diagram of the stone with its inclusions marked. People glance at it, count the marks and feel discouraged.

Count is not the point. Position is. An inclusion in the centre, under the table, is in the worst place it could be. The same inclusion near the girdle may sit under a claw and be invisible forever. A diagram with several marks around the edge can describe a better-looking stone than one with a single mark in the middle.

The diagram is also how a specific stone is identified later, which matters if it ever leaves your possession for repair or resizing.

What the report deliberately does not say

What it is worth. No figure, by design. Valuation is a separate exercise done for insurance, drawing on the report but not part of it.

How it looks. Two stones with identical grades across every line can look different side by side. Grading captures a great deal and not everything — brightness in dim light, how the stone behaves as it moves. This is the single most important limitation of the document and the reason buying from a spreadsheet goes wrong. The entry on the four Cs makes the same argument from the other direction.

Lab-grown stones on the same document

Lab-grown diamonds are graded by the same laboratories, on the same scales, using the same vocabulary, and the report states plainly that the stone was grown rather than mined. There is nothing hidden in the formatting and nothing to decode.

Most lab-grown stones also carry an inscription on the girdle, readable under magnification, tying the physical stone to its report number. If you are ever unsure that the document in your hand describes the stone in your hand, that is how it is checked. Any jeweller can do it while you wait.

Checking the report is real

Every major laboratory publishes a free online lookup. Enter the report number and compare what comes back against the paper.

Do this. It takes a minute, it is the only step in this entire subject that is purely mechanical, and it is the one most people skip.

Reading one in the right order

Cut grade or proportions first. Measurements second. Clarity only to the extent of whether anything is visible unaided. Colour against the metal you have chosen. Carat weight last, as a consequence rather than a target.

That order is roughly the reverse of how the document is laid out and roughly the reverse of how it is usually presented to a buyer, which tells you something about who the layout is for.

For a commission the report arrives after the stone exists, so the specification is agreed first and the document confirms it. If you would like us to walk through one line by line before anything is set, that is a normal part of the process rather than a favour.

Begin with a conversation.

Begin an enquiry